A Preacher's Dark Confession

In this chilling Halloween story, we uncover the shocking truth behind Rebekah Gay’s disappearance on October 31, 2012. What began as a missing person case led authorities to an unexpected suspect: a pastor and her soon-to-be stepfather, John White. As investigators closed in, White confessed to a horrifying crime, revealing a dark past with a disturbing pattern of violence and twisted fantasies. Join us as we unravel how a trusted figure hid his monstrous tendencies behind a façade of faith, and the haunting legacy Rebekah's story leaves as a reminder of the danger that can hide in plain sight.