Controversial Cases

Join us this February as we explore controversial cases from the recent and distant past

Timothy Reynolds and Tales From the Underworld

Feb 04, 2026

Controversial Cases

This month, Tales From the Underworld brings you an assortment of controversial cases from the recent and distant past. From questionable courtroom decisions to suspicious suicide rulings, these cases will leave you wondering if justice was really served.

Help us keep publishing the stories that matter

Behind every story we publish is a small team of true crime writers and researchers putting in the work to get it right. That means chasing down primary sources, cross-checking timelines, and rewriting until the narrative is clear, accurate, and respectful to the people at the center of these cases.

If you’ve been reading for a while, you already know this isn’t content we can crank out on autopilot. These stories take time—and that time is what makes them worth reading.

This month, we’re offering a discount for anyone who wants to help keep the writing going. Your subscription directly supports our team and protects the hours it takes to research, write, edit, and publish consistently—so we can keep bringing you new cases all February (and beyond).

Become a Paid Supporter

Disappearances and Missing Persons

Last month, we brought you more chilling tales of disappearances and missing persons. These strange and tragic cases left us with many more questions than answers.

Here are some of the cases that gripped our readers: