Tales From the Underworld — Authentic True Crime

Tales From the Underworld — Authentic True Crime

Home
Notes
Halloween
Podcast
Explore
Archive
Newsletters
Leaderboard
About

Illinois

Disappearance in Decatur: The Tragic Abduction and Murder of Penny Timmons
On Halloween 1992, 20-year-old Penny Timmons was abducted from her workplace in Decatur, Illinois and was missing for more than a year before the case…
 • 
Donna Patton
1
"G.I. Joe's" Widow Receives Settlement: Melodie Gliniewicz and Pension Board Come to Agreement
In November 2024, the Fox Lake Village Board and the Fox Lake Police Pension Board came to an agreement with the widow of disgraced former police…
 • 
Donna Patton
"Old Blue Eyes" and the Mob: Investigating Frank Sinatra's Organized Crime Ties
For years, rumors have persisted that iconic American singer and actor Frank Sinatra was connected to underworld figures. In fact, the FBI kept a file…
 • 
Timothy Reynolds
The Shelton Brothers
The Forgotten Depression Era Gang That Battled the Law, the KKK, and the Chicago Outfit
 • 
Timothy Reynolds
 and 
Sha Cabral
7:14
The Shelton Brothers: The Forgotten Depression Era Gang That Battled the Law, the KKK, and the Chicago Outfit
From the early 1920s through the late 1940s, the Shelton Gang controlled much of the illegal vice trade in southern Illinois. Their reign was…
 • 
Timothy Reynolds
Midwest Mayhem: The Terrifying Tale of a Shadowy Serial Killer Known as "Billy the Axeman"
In the early 1900s, several families in the midwest and elsewhere were savagely murdered by an unidentified killer. Now, modern researchers believe they…
 • 
Kirsten Ford
The Criminal Career and Strange Disappearance of "Gentleman" Outlaw Charles "Black Bart" Boles
Charles “Black Bart” Boles robbed stagecoaches and left behind poetic messages to taunt authorities. The gentleman bandit who created his own legend…
 • 
Donna Patton
From Hero to Criminal: The Shocking Deception and Fall From Grace of Police Lt. Joe "G.I. Joe" Gliniewicz
In September 2015, beloved Fox Lake police lieutenant Joe Gliniewicz was found dead after alerting dispatchers he was chasing 3 suspects. The ensuing…
 • 
Kates Lara
Betrayed By "The Woman In Red": The Death Of John Dillinger
When Chicago resident Ana Sage suddenly found herself living with the notorious John Dillinger, she made a deal with law enforcement to betray him, only…
 • 
Timothy Reynolds
When Feared Outfit Enforcer Tony Spilotro Went Into Business for Himself, He and His Brother were Savagely Murdered
In 1986, the bodies of Tony and Michael Spilotro were discovered buried on an Indiana farm. The identity of their killers and the details of the murders…
 • 
Timothy Reynolds
In 1962, Two Thieves Were Found Stuffed In A Car Trunk on Chicago's South Side. The Killings Dubbed the "M&M Murders" Went Unsolved for Over…
Billy McCarthy and Jimmy Miraglia were two Chicago hoodlums who ran afoul of the powerful Chicago Outfit and paid with their lives. The murders went…
 • 
Timothy Reynolds
1
The "Ripper Crew" was a Group of Serial Killers Who Brought a Reign of Terror to Chicago During the 1980s
The Ripper Crew were Sadistic Killers who Abducted and Tortured Young Women In Chicago During the Early 1980s.
 • 
Vanessa Smith
© 2025 Tales From the Underworld
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture